History is subject to geology. Every day the sea encroaches somewhere upon the land, or the land upon the sea; cities disappear under the water, and sunken cathedrals ring their melancholy bells. Mountains rise and fall in the rhythm of emergence and erosion; rivers swell and flood, or dry up, or change their course; valleys become deserts, and isthmuses become straits. To the geologic eye all the surface of the earth is a fluid form, and man moves upon it as insecurely as Peter walking on the waves to Christ. | |
— Will and Ariel Durant | |
From their book: “The Lessons Of History“ | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2020 | A Humbling Learning Process |
They Are All Good | |
2019 | Another Thought On #45’s Poor Education |
2018 | As Long As You Survive Each Experience |
WordPress to Facebook Test… | |
Day 7: Oh, Yeah! | |
2017 | A Good Habit |
2016 | The Minds Of Trumpism |
2015 | Expressing Nonsense |
2014 | A Real Fight |
2013 | Unravelling |
2012 | I Resolve |
2011 | Practice, Practice, Practice |
2009 | Phoenix Trip (July ’09) |
Posts Tagged ‘Will Durant’
And Due To Be More Fluid
Posted in Environment, History, Philosophy, Quotes, Science and Learning, tagged Environment, Geology, History, Jesus Christ, Philosophy, Quotes, Saint Peter, Science, The Lessons Of History, Walking On Water, Will and Ariel Durant, Will Durant on August 3, 2021| Leave a Comment »
Kinda Like Posting To A Blog About My Day
Posted in History, Quotes, tagged Blogging, Complexity, Comprehension, Faces, Facts, History, Oversimplification, Quotes, Will Durant on December 7, 2020| Leave a Comment »
The historian always oversimplifies, and hastily selects a manageable minority of facts and faces out of a crowd of souls and events whose multitudinous complexity he can never quite embrace or comprehend. | |
— Will Durant | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2021 | A Tenacious Cycle |
Once Upon A Time… | |
2020 | Kinda Like Posting To A Blog About My Day |
Just A Different Point Of View | |
You Be The Judge | |
2019 | I Think I’m Repeating Myself |
It’s Beginning To Look A Lot Like X-mas! | |
2018 | No Reason To Turn |
2017 | Talking Knuth |
Seeing It Through | |
2016 | Hoping For The Best Come January |
2015 | Adaptive Security |
2014 | Wants |
2013 | Side Effects |
2012 | Just Trying To Earn A Living |
2011 | Productive Worry |
A Short History
Posted in 2020 Book Review, Book Review, Education, History, Philosophy, Reading, Reviews, Science and Learning, tagged 2020 Book Review, Ariel Durant, Education, Highly Recommended Book, History, Melting-Pot American, Philosophy, The Lessons Of History -- book review, The Story Of Civilization, Will and Ariel Durant, Will Durant on October 10, 2020| Leave a Comment »
“The Lessons Of History” (1968©) — book review | |
Today’s book review is for a summation / distillation book written by Will and Ariel Durant (a married couple) which culminates a series of eleven volumes popularly titled: “The Story of Civilization“. This book (“Lessons“) actually was written and published between volumes 10 and 11 of that main work. The book attempts to provide extremely brief points about twelve topics: geography, biology, race, character, morals, religion, economics, socialism, government, war, growth / decay, and progress. There is also a preface and a first chapter detailing the authors “hesitations” in presenting such a précis. The book is barely 117 pages while the typical main volume is 900-1100 pages (over 10,000 pages in total). Obviously, their task was daunting and, generally speaking, they only compare / contrast the two main tensions (positions) for each topic (i.e. religion vs secularism) in this slim book. This book, like the main series, is an attempt to bring “history” to the masses (in simple, if flowery, language). | |
If you are a lover of words, you will enjoy the authors’ writing style. I found the imagery almost poetic at many points. If, however, you are a person grounded in ideas, you may be less taken by this work. The chapters tend to be limited to the “compare and contrast” formula of only two main concepts each per topic. Another issue: the book is dealing with racism and culture, character and morals, etc., and many times we see these topics through the prism of our modern perspective, while the authors view them over the course of human history. Racism and slavery, for example, seem almost excused because that’s the way it (humanity) has been for the vast majority of the last 5,000 years. It is NOT excused (by the authors), but it is detailed and in most sections comes across as “the white-man’s destiny”, until suddenly – sometimes in only a single brief paragraph, it isn’t. And the “suddenly” paragraph represents the last 150 years which some of us have lived through a fair chunk of – in my case 65 of them, anyway. I am not trying to be critical of the couple’s monumental work (over five decades in the writing for the main series), however, this book seems to suffer from the same European / Northern Mediterranean perspective (i.e. bias) which the main series is always criticized for. I did not personally find this overly objectionable, but then I am a “melting-pot” American (product of the 1960’s). | |
Is this a good book? Is it thought provoking? Is it entertaining? Yes. Yes. And, yes. There is a well known expression that those who forget history are doomed to repeat it. The authors opine this is not necessarily as true as is the subtle appearance of time, leadership, government and civilization being caught up in great interweaving cycles – like a pendulum we swing back and forth between anarchy and tyranny with only brief periods of democratic liberties and freedoms. And, they attempt to illustrate this series of cycles for each of the twelve chapters opposing extremes. Please note: the authors imagery is circular. Mine is the pendulum. | |
Final recommendation: highly recommended! I bought the full twelve volumes several years ago and promised myself I’d read them “eventually”. I’m glad I’ve finally dipped my toe in the ocean. I guess the next step is to begin the real swim… | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2021 | Chaos Theory |
Too Few | |
2020 | What About Blog Posts? |
Listenin’ By Myself | |
A Short History | |
2019 | Dodgers Choke AGAIN |
He Wasn’t “Just Kidding The Press” | |
2018 | Thinking About My Hil |
Remember Your Duty In November | |
2017 | Play Well With Others |
2016 | Surviving And Challenging |
2015 | On Destroying Historic / Archaeological Sites |
2014 | Magical Power |
2013 | How Awesome Would That Be |
2012 | Two Views |
2011 | Still Looking For Examples |
2010 | Giants Win Away 3 – 2!! |
Was #IncompenentDonald Born To Be A Diplomat?
Posted in Politics, Quotes, tagged #IncompetentDonald, Diplomacy, Politics, Quotes, Speaking, Will Durant on June 10, 2020| Leave a Comment »
To say nothing, especially when speaking, is half the art of diplomacy. | |
— Will Durant | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2019 | Have You Planted Lately? |
2018 | Something / Nothing |
2017 | Kindness |
2016 | Dealing With It |
2015 | Too Many Choices! |
2014 | Vini, Vidi, Vici |
2013 | Heroes |
Education, n. | |
2012 | Who I Want To Be |
2011 | Mythic Forgetfulness |
What Is True For War Is Also True For Elections
Posted in History, Politics, Quotes, tagged Bitter Lesson, Civilization, Dry Powder, Elections, Eternal Vigilance, History, Peace, Politics, Quotes, The History of Civilization: Our Oriental Heritage, The Price Of Civilization, Tragedy, Will Durant on July 31, 2019| Leave a Comment »
The bitter lesson that may be drawn from this tragedy is that eternal vigilance is the price of civilization. A nation must love peace, but keep its powder dry. | |
— Will Durant | |
From his book: “The History of Civilization: Our Oriental Heritage“ | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2018 | Start By Trying |
Day 4: Difficult Day | |
2017 | Outlasting Division |
2016 | Said The Man Who Trained To Fight For A Living |
2015 | Tripping On Treasure |
2014 | The Flower Of Light |
2013 | Eye Catching |
2012 | The Holstee Manifesto |
2011 | Three Crooners For The Shower |
The Soldier’s Faith | |
Vacation, Books And Lots Of Movies | |
First From Within
Posted in History, Quotes, tagged Greece, Greek Civilization, History, Quotes, Roman Conquest, The History of Civilization: The Life of Greece, Will Durant on October 2, 2018| Leave a Comment »
We have tried to show that the essential cause of the Roman conquest of Greece was the disintegration of Greek civilization from within. No great nation is ever conquered until it has destroyed itself. | |
— Will Durant | |
From his book: “The History of Civilization: The Life of Greece“ | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2021 | Give It Time |
Spending That Last Dime | |
2020 | I Like The Feeling |
Everything I Hoped For | |
Let The Landslide Begin!! | |
2019 | Somebody’s Watching You |
2018 | First From Within |
2017 | Or Vote Against You |
2016 | Cupid Must Say It Too |
2015 | Some Of This And A Pinch Of That |
2014 | Consensus Is Only One Side |
2013 | Not Ought |
2012 | If You Want To, If You Have Something To Offer |
2011 | I See Lots Of Fools |
2010 | Orange Inside!! |
And The Band Played On… | |
Happy New Year!! | |
Steps
Posted in History, Quotes, Reading, tagged François-Marie Arouet, History, Quotes, Reading Goals, The Story Of Civilization, The Story Of Civilization: I - Our Oriental Heritage, Voltaire, Will Durant on July 21, 2015| Leave a Comment »
A history of civilization shares the presumptuousness of every philosophical enterprise: it offers the ridiculous spectacle of a fragment expounding the whole. Like philosophy, such a venture has no rational excuse, and is at best but a brave stupidity; but let us hope that, like philosophy, it will always lure some rash spirits into its fatal depths. | |
— Will Durant | |
From the Preface to the first volume to his series: “The Story Of Civilization: I – Our Oriental Heritage“ | |
I want to know what were the steps by which men passed from barbarism to civilization. | |
— Voltaire | |
[Several years ago, I purchased the book series “The Story Of Civilization” by Will (and Ariel) Durant. I first heard about the series perhaps forty years ago, when I was first thinking (and hoping) to “become” educated and cultured by reading great books and listening to classical music. I found the books on sale at a used book store and picked them up as a promise to myself. Since then, they’ve been sitting on my shelf calling to me… Recently, I pulled down the first volume and started glancing through it. Okay, I actually started to read it. | |
There are twelve volumes in the series and with one exception each is at least 1,000 pages. When I looked the series up on line, one reviewer said any serious reader should expect to spend five years of his life reading these in their entirety, because anything less would fail to give them the consideration and justice they deserved. Talk about your intimidating review!! | |
I doubt if I’ll finish them in five years. I doubt if I’ll be able to find the time to give them the consideration they probably deserve. But if I start now, who can say… | |
Fortunately, I do not feel foolish enough to set a goal of understanding all of human history or even to remember most of the 12,000+ pages related in this series. I only hope to understand a little better how I got here (in this time and place) and what my minor role is in this great river of history. — kmab] | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2014 | To Be Greatly Good |
2013 | Limited Capacity |
2012 | Two Ear Ticklers |
Justification | |
2011 | To Avail The Nation |
It Took Roots
Posted in History, Quotes, tagged History, Michelangelo, On Civilization, On Money, On The Renaissance, Quotes, The History of Civilization: The Renaissance, Titian, Will Durant on May 20, 2015| Leave a Comment »
But it took more than a revival of antiquity to make the Renaissance. And first of all it took money — smelly bourgeois money: … of careful calculations, investments and loans, of interest and dividends accumulated until surplus could be spared from the pleasures of the flesh, from the purchase of senates, signories, and mistresses, to pay a Michelangelo or a Titian to transmute wealth into beauty, and perfume a fortune with the breath of art. Money is the root of all civilization. | |
— Will Durant | |
From his book: “The History of Civilization: The Renaissance“ | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2014 | Hard Evidence |
2013 | Full Participation |
2012 | Roving (Again) |
Ooops, Again | |
2011 | Why Not? |
Warning
Posted in History, Politics, Quotes, tagged History, On Politics, On Rome, On The Concentration Of Wealth, Quotes, The History of Civilization: Caesar and Christ, Will Durant on May 10, 2015| Leave a Comment »
The new generation, having inherited world mastery, had no time or inclination to defend it; that readiness for war which had characterized the Roman landowner disappeared now that ownership was concentrated in a few families and a proletariat without stake in the country filled the slums of Rome. | |
— Will Durant | |
From his book: “The History of Civilization: Caesar and Christ“ | |
[A cautionary note to the 1%… — KMAB] | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2014 | Always More Productive |
2013 | Is Not |
2012 | Loosely Translated |
2011 | Your Opinions Are Not My Facts |
Absorbed And Civilized
Posted in History, Quotes, tagged On China, On History, Quotes, The History of Civilization: Our Oriental Heritage, Will Durant on February 25, 2015| Leave a Comment »
[On China in 1935…] No victory of arms, or tyranny of alien finance, can long suppress a nation so rich in resources and vitality. The invader will lose funds or patience before the loins of China will lose virility; within a century China will have absorbed and civilized her conquerors, and will have learned all the technique of what transiently bears the name of modern industry; roads and communications will give her unity, economy and thrift will give her funds, and a strong government will give her order and peace. | |
— Will Durant | |
From his book: “The History of Civilization: Our Oriental Heritage“ | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | Until Something Better Comes Along |
2021 | Facing The Headwinds |
Still Thankful, Still Don’t Read Well | |
2020 | Write For Yourself |
2019 | I’m Actively Irresponsible |
2018 | I Will Love You… Forever |
2017 | Pebbles In Your Shoe? |
2016 | Resolute Will |
2015 | Absorbed And Civilized |
2014 | Relax And Lead |
2013 | Location, Location, Location |
2012 | Are You Really Good? |
2011 | Relatively Objective, Anyway |
A Roman Rome
Posted in Uncategorized, tagged On History, On The Assimilation Of Immigrants, Quotes, Rome, The History of Civilization: Caesar and Christ, Will Durant on February 2, 2015| 1 Comment »
If Rome had not engulfed so many men of alien blood in so brief a time, if she had passed all these newcomers through her schools instead of her slums, if she had treated them as men with a hundred potential excellences, if she had occasionally closed her gates to let assimilation catch up with infiltration, she might have gained new racial and literary vitality from the infusion, and might have remained a Roman Rome, the voice and citadel of the West. | |
— Will Durant | |
From his book: “The History of Civilization: Caesar and Christ“ | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | A Clear View Of #45 |
2021 | Not Here, Not Again |
Will The Senate Convict An Insurrectionist? | |
2020 | Senate Perfidy |
2019 | Contributing To Congress |
Yellow Signs Of Spring | |
2018 | But Take Heart |
Poetic Marker | |
2017 | The Few, The Many, The Most |
2016 | To My Brother |
2015 | For Junior |
A Roman Rome | |
2014 | Hmmm |
2013 | What’s A Motto With You? |
2012 | Worthy Companions |
2011 | Bourne Again |
Which Ten Are You In? | |
Pursuing Perspective
Posted in History, Philosophy, Quotes, tagged History, On Mankind, On Perspective, Philosophy, Quotes, The History of Civilization: Our Oriental Heritage, Will Durant on January 27, 2015| Leave a Comment »
I wish to tell as much as I can, in as little space as I can, of the contributions that genius and labor have made to the cultural heritage of mankind – to chronicle and contemplate, in their causes, character and effects, the advances of invention, the varieties of economic organization, the experiments in government, the aspirations of religion, the mutations of morals and manners, the masterpieces of literature, the development of science, the wisdom of philosophy, and the achievements of art. I do not need to be told how absurd this enterprise is, nor how immodest is its very conception … Nevertheless I have dreamed that despite the many errors inevitable in this undertaking, it may be of some use to those upon whom the passion for philosophy has laid the compulsion to try to see things whole, to pursue perspective, unity and time, as well as to seek them through science in space. … Like philosophy, such a venture [as the creation of these 11 volumes] has no rational excuse, and is at best but a brave stupidity; but let us hope that, like philosophy, it will always lure some rash spirits into its fatal depths. | |
— Will Durant | |
From the preface of his book: “The History of Civilization: Our Oriental Heritage“ | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | Are You Confused? |
2021 | Working On The Ordinary |
Smoothed My Jagged Edges | |
2020 | Republican Senators Should Vote For Conviction Of #45 |
2019 | Carry It |
2018 | Simple |
2017 | Knowledge Pays |
2016 | Brief Glimpses And Full Glances |
2015 | Pursuing Perspective |
2014 | Wearing Down? |
2013 | Labouring Under A Curse |
2012 | Listen To Yourself |
2011 | Career Tips (Part 1) |
No Captain Dunsel | |
More Likely
Posted in Environment, My Journal, Quotes, tagged Environment, My Journal, Quotes, Will Durant on December 14, 2014| 3 Comments »
Perhaps man, having remade his environment, will turn around at last and begin to remake himself. | |
— Will Durant | |
[More likely, having destroyed the environment, man will be replaced by a new “dominant” species on Earth. — kmab] | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2021 | Just Catching My Breath |
I Still Believe | |
2020 | Sometimes It Does |
Sweet As Rain Upon My Tongue | |
2019 | Pushing The Envelope |
2018 | The Price Of Justice Is (Sometimes) Security |
2017 | Time Too |
2016 | The Cornerstone Pays |
2015 | Would That This Be True |
2014 | More Likely |
2013 | Enjoyed The Desolation |
Watching Faux News | |
2012 | Speaking Of Products |
2011 | Ready To Be Immortal? |
Live, Then, As If…
Posted in Philosophy, Quotes, tagged André Maurois, On Death, On Life, On Life After Death, On the Meaning of Life, Philosophy, Quotes, Will Durant on November 10, 2013| 4 Comments »
What shall we know of our death? Either the soul is immortal and we shall not die, or it perishes with the flesh and we shall not know that we are dead. Live, then, as if you were eternal, and do not believe that your life has changed merely because it seems proved that the Earth is empty. You do not live in the Earth, you live in yourself. | |
— André Maurois | |
Quoted by Will Durant | |
From his book: “On the Meaning of Life“ | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2021 | My Thoughts On Global Climate Change |
And Never Understand | |
2020 | Waiting For 20 January 2021 |
#45: You Would Cry Too… | |
2019 | #Corrupt45 Fails Another Great Test |
2018 | Where The Economy Is Headed Thanks To #IncompetentDonald |
2017 | Time For More Research, Too |
2016 | Original Thoughts |
2015 | If They’re Good Enough |
2014 | Three… |
2013 | Uncle Joe’s Song |
Live, Then, As If… | |
2012 | Still Trying |
2011 | Not Deserving |