“X+Y” (2014) — movie review, released in the US as “A Brilliant Young Mind” (2015) | |
Today’s review is for the 2014 / 2015 movie “X+Y“, aka: “A Brilliant Young Mind“. The movie stars Asa Butterfield as Nathan Ellis (autistic math genius), Rafe Spall as Martin Humphreys (Nathan’s tutor), Sally Hawkins as Julie Ellis (Nathan’s mum), Eddie Marsan as Richard (UK tutor), Jo Yang as Zhang Mei (Nathan’s love interest), Martin McCann as Michael Ellis (Nathan’s dad), Jake Davies as Luke Shelton (mocked math genius), Alex Lawther as Isaac Cooper (mocking math genius), Alexa Davies as Rebecca Dunn (Piano girl / jealous crush). | |
There is something called the “International Mathematics Olympiad” (IMO) which brings together all of the maths geniuses from around the world to compete on their respective national teams. It seems China is the historically dominant power at this event. | |
Nathan is an autistic maths wiz. The only person he is close with is his dad who dies in a car accident. The accident makes Nathan even more reclusive / eccentric than he was before. | |
Nathan’s mum (the fish lady / maid in “The Shape of Water“) is not able to relate with her son and finally gets a piece of relief by shipping him off to compete in the IMO. Nathan’s tutor (Martin) is himself a “failed” maths prodigy and slowly builds a relationship with Nathan and his mum. Eddie Marsan plays the UK team manager who’s only concern is for the team to beat the Chinese team. Zhang Mei is Nathan’s “love” interest. He slowly pries Nathan from his turtle shell. Martin McCann is Nathan’s dad and is the only one who sees him as special and not weird. At least that is how Nathan feels. The final three main characters (Luke, Isaac and Rebecca) are other “kids” on the IMO team who are meant to demonstrate some other levels of autism or to act as a kind of alternative love interest. | |
Is this movie any good? Does it say anything about math? Does it say anything about kids? Does it say anything about autism? Yes, a little, nothing new, and I don’t know. | |
I really enjoyed this movie. I got interested in it a while back when I saw Butterfield in “Ender’s War” and thought I’d look out for any of his other work. (I’ve seen the previews for this film and the bits and bobs available on YouTube and have been waiting for this movie to become available on cable or on Vudu.) Now I’ve seen him in two very good roles and it will be interesting to see if he develops into a good adult actor or if he fades. As with “Ender“, Asa plays the straight role well and the emotional role almost as well. I don’t really understand autism, so I can’t say how accurately he portrayed the ending transformation. My gut feeling was it was too Hollywood and not realistic, but that just may be me. | |
The movie relates math to various aspects of the real world: pattern recognition, music, art, architecture, philosophy and love. They were not main points of the film though, so if you blink, you may miss a couple of them. | |
I don’t think this movie says anything original about kids. Certainly nothing you couldn’t get from a half-dozen other movies starting with “Lord of the Flies“. Yes, kids are mean and pick on other kids who may be viewed as somehow “different”. | |
As mentioned above, Nathan is “transformed” at the end of the movie. I doubt autism is cured on the road to Damascus, so I didn’t care for the resolution / summing up. It just seemed too tidy for my taste. Apparently, the movie is based on a real-life person and his reaction to viewing the film was: “I am a maths wiz. I am not a rain man.” For me, to the extent the movie related Nathan’s love for math, I felt it stood on firmer ground. | |
Final recommendation: very strong to highly. I do have an “unusual” fondness for movies with even the slightest math / science / computing theme, so you have to take this recommendation with the normal grain of salt you take my reviews… (LOL) I’m not usually a big fan of hazy / distorted filming to represent the perception of genius, but in this case, it worked pretty well. I liked the acting, the story and loose correlation of math to music, color, flow and pattern recognition. I will watch it again in the future. | |
One final note: I got to see this movie for free! I joined my local library (re-joined) and they have a pretty interesting selection of movies you can stream just for being a member of the library. It saved me having to purchase a movie I really wanted to see. They do limit my viewing to eight per calendar month, but it still seems a great deal to me! Who knew?? | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | Sometimes I’m Confused |
2021 | You Need Me On That Wall |
Counting Bees And Chasing Clouds | |
2020 | Precious Life |
2019 | Nothing Is Too Difficult For Me |
Patterns Of Caring | |
2018 | And May Never Be |
2017 | Don’t Forget |
2016 | I Was A Percentage Man |
2015 | It Waits Patiently |
2014 | Unknown |
2013 | Explaining Love? |
2012 | Echoes of 1% |
2011 | Salaam, Egypt!! |
Where Do You Learn? | |
Archive for January, 2019
Patterns Of Caring
Posted in Education, Health, Movie Review, Movies, Reviews, Science and Learning, tagged A Brilliant Young Mind -- movie review, Alex Lawther, Alexa Davies, Asa Butterfield, Autism, China, Eddie Marsan, Genius, IMO, International Mathematics Olympiad, Isaac Cooper, Jake Davies, Jo Yang, Julie Ellis, Luke Shelton, Martin Humphreys, Martin McCann, Mathematics, Michael Ellis, Nathan Ellis, Rafe Spall, Rebecca Dunn, Sally Hawkins, Very Strong to Highly Rcommended Movie, X+Y -- movie review, Zhang Mei on January 31, 2019| 2 Comments »
Nothing Is Too Difficult For Me
Posted in Humor, Philosophy, Quotes, tagged Desire, Honesty, Humor, John of the Cross, Nothing, Philosophy, Quotes, Satisfaction on January 31, 2019| 4 Comments »
To achieve satisfaction in everything desire it in nothing. To possess everything, desire to have nothing. To be everything, desire to be nothing. To know everything, desire to know nothing. | |
— John of the Cross | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | Sometimes I’m Confused |
2021 | You Need Me On That Wall |
Counting Bees And Chasing Clouds | |
2020 | Precious Life |
2019 | Nothing Is Too Difficult For Me |
Patterns Of Caring | |
2018 | And May Never Be |
2017 | Don’t Forget |
2016 | I Was A Percentage Man |
2015 | It Waits Patiently |
2014 | Unknown |
2013 | Explaining Love? |
2012 | Echoes of 1% |
2011 | Salaam, Egypt!! |
Where Do You Learn? | |
17 Days Until The Next Government Shutdown
Posted in Leadership, Philosophy, Politics, Quotes, tagged #DumbDonald, #IncompetentTrump, Apples, Compromise, George Bernard Shaw, Government Shutdown, Ideas, Philosophy, Political Leadership, Politics, Quotes on January 30, 2019| 3 Comments »
If you have an apple and I have an apple and we exchange these apples then you and I will still each have one apple. But if you have an idea and I have an idea and we exchange these ideas, then each of us will have two ideas. | ||
― George Bernard Shaw | ||
. | ||
On This Day In: | ||
2022 | There Is No Fate But What You Make | |
2021 | The Silent Word | |
Touched My Hand | ||
2020 | Releasing Their Fears | |
2019 | 17 Days Until The Next Government Shutdown | |
2018 | Disciplined Models | |
2017 | We Cannot Afford Enemies | |
2016 | Love Is Just A State Of Mind | |
2015 | Waiting? | |
2014 | Big C, Little B (II) | |
Where God Has Not | ||
2013 | Chasing His Dragon | |
Shaped And Molded | ||
2012 | Believe In Yourself | |
2011 | Cultural Equivalence | |
Why Not? | ||
Books About Books | ||
The Basis For Adult Continuing Education | ||
Looks A Lot Like #45
Posted in Humor, Politics, Quotes, tagged #45, #DumbDonald, Groucho Marx, Humor, Idiots, Politics, Quotes on January 29, 2019| Leave a Comment »
He may look like an idiot and talk like an idiot but don’t let that fool you. He really is an idiot. | |
― Groucho Marx | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | A Murmuring Note |
2021 | Satisfied If Not Fulfilled |
You Don’t Know | |
Urban Ballroom | |
2020 | R.I.P. Kobe |
2019 | Looks A Lot Like #45 |
2018 | Trying To Stay Young |
2017 | Seems Reasonable To Me |
2016 | We Can Get Through This Together (In Time) |
2015 | How Long Is A Piece Of String? |
2014 | Heathen, n. |
2013 | Wisdom’s Folly |
2012 | When The Student Is Ready |
Disconnected Leadership | |
2011 | The Complex Richness Of Life |
Your Own Blog Posts
Posted in Quotes, tagged Bible, Blog Posts, Quotes, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Readings, Trumpet on January 28, 2019| 5 Comments »
Make your own Bible. Select and collect all the words and sentences that in all your readings have been to you like the blast of a trumpet. | |
― Ralph Waldo Emerson | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | A Happy Realization |
2021 | Is Science Cumulative? |
We’re Aging With Time | |
2020 | Where #45 Is Leading The Republican Party |
2019 | Your Own Blog Posts |
The Man With A Code | |
2018 | Choose Goodness |
2017 | Developing Translations |
2016 | Think Like A Hero |
2015 | Reductionism |
2014 | Gravitation, n. |
2013 | Ups And Downs |
2012 | Nerd Heard – And Good-Bye |
Your Continuum | |
2011 | Career Tips (Part 2) |
Carry It
Posted in Philosophy, Quotes, tagged Beauty, Philosophy, Quotes, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Travel on January 27, 2019| 1 Comment »
Though we travel the world over to find the beautiful, we must carry it with us, or we find it not. | |
― Ralph Waldo Emerson | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | Are You Confused? |
2021 | Working On The Ordinary |
Smoothed My Jagged Edges | |
2020 | Republican Senators Should Vote For Conviction Of #45 |
2019 | Carry It |
2018 | Simple |
2017 | Knowledge Pays |
2016 | Brief Glimpses And Full Glances |
2015 | Pursuing Perspective |
2014 | Wearing Down? |
2013 | Labouring Under A Curse |
2012 | Listen To Yourself |
2011 | Career Tips (Part 1) |
No Captain Dunsel | |
Finishing Work
Posted in Philosophy, Quotes, tagged Ambition, Attitude, Philosophy, Prize, Quotes, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Winning, Work on January 26, 2019| Leave a Comment »
Without ambition one starts nothing. Without work one finishes nothing. The prize will not be sent to you. You have to win it. | |
― Ralph Waldo Emerson | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | An Experiment Without A Control Group |
2021 | Seeking Center |
Your Love Is Near | |
2020 | You Mean I’m STILL In School? |
2019 | Finishing Work |
2018 | Diversity |
2017 | Timely Planning |
2016 | Just Too Easy To Know Fewer And Fewer |
2015 | A Fine Balance |
2014 | Next Rung |
2013 | Super Bowl Prep |
Romantics | |
A Goal For Zen? | |
2012 | Mutant Powers Of Obsession |
2011 | Federal Stars |
Mud Pie | |
And Government Shutdowns, Too
Posted in Politics, Quotes, tagged Debt Limit, Politics, Quotes, Reputation, Warren Buffett, Weapon of Mass Destruction on January 25, 2019| Leave a Comment »
I think that both parties should declare the debt limit as a political weapon of mass destruction which can’t be used. I mean, it is silly to have a country that has 237 years building up its reputation and then have people threaten to tear it down because they’re not getting some other matter. | |
— Warren Buffett | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | The Fight Continues… |
2021 | Short, Swift, Haste |
Another Friend’s Passing | |
2020 | Can We At Least Set The Bar Higher Than An Incompetent Liar In The Oval Office? |
2019 | Uncertain Times |
And Government Shutdowns, Too | |
2018 | Satisfied |
2017 | In The Mind |
2016 | Dreaming |
2015 | The Best Medicine Is Also Contagious |
2014 | Eyes Off |
2013 | The More Things Change… |
2012 | The Delicate Moment Of Giving |
2011 | Ready, Shoot, Aim!! |
Uncertain Times
Posted in Philosophy, Quotes, tagged Philosophy, Quotes, Time, Uncertainty, Warren Buffett on January 25, 2019| Leave a Comment »
You know, people talk about this being an uncertain time. You know, all time is uncertain. I mean, it was uncertain back in – in 2007, we just didn’t know it was uncertain. It was – uncertain on September 10th, 2001. It was uncertain on October 18th, 1987, you just didn’t know it. | |
— Warren Buffett | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | The Fight Continues… |
2021 | Short, Swift, Haste |
Another Friend’s Passing | |
2020 | Can We At Least Set The Bar Higher Than An Incompetent Liar In The Oval Office? |
2019 | Uncertain Times |
And Government Shutdowns, Too | |
2018 | Satisfied |
2017 | In The Mind |
2016 | Dreaming |
2015 | The Best Medicine Is Also Contagious |
2014 | Eyes Off |
2013 | The More Things Change… |
2012 | The Delicate Moment Of Giving |
2011 | Ready, Shoot, Aim!! |
Interesting, But Not Fascinating
Posted in Philosophy, Quotes, tagged Garden, Leonard Nimoy, Life, Live Long And Prosper, LLAP, Me Being Me, Memory, Moments, Numbers, On Being Fascinating, Palindrome, Philosophy, Quotes on January 24, 2019| 7 Comments »
A life is like a garden. Perfect moments can be had, but not preserved, except in memory. LLAP | |
— Leonard Nimoy | |
Back in January (click here), I posted the observation that I had just reached 1,221 email followers. I found this an “interesting” number because it is a palindrome (reads the same backwards as forwards). I also mentioned that I was looking forward to reaching 1,234 followers. Again, solely because it is an interesting number: the earliest sequential number number possible with four digits. | |
![]() |
|
Today, I hit “1,235” email followers. Now, some may ask why is that worth noting when I never posted anything about 1,234. Three reasons… | |
First: The “achievement” was a milestone, but it was not a goal. To me, a goal is the end – like a world championship. A milestone is a step along the way – all of the wins (and losses) along the way to reaching the goal. I would argue, the steps you take to reach the next milestone are as significant in reaching the goal as reaching each milestone. And, many times, the road is as important as the destination. | |
Second: The “achievement” was transitory. The morning I woke up and found I hit 1,235 (first time), I had actually missed seeing the “milestone” (1,234) because I’d picked up two new followers overnight. This highlighted the transitory nature of arbitrary milestones. I have since seen (and reached) “1,234” followers several times since then. For whatever reason, some of my followers stopped following and I have also gained others. I have actually been back down to 1,232. | |
I don’t really know why I gain or lose followers. I can only say I gain and lose most followers around days when I post about politics (criticizing Trump) or religion – particularly if I post a series (three of four days in a row). There seems to be a tolerance level for followers: one or two times is okay, but don’t keep beating the same drum. And, that’s okay, I’m often tempted to do the same with blogs I follow. I don’t, but I am tempted. LOL. | |
And, third: in it’s own way, “1,235” is more interesting than “1,234”. For the latter, adding the first digit to each in the sequence produces the next in the sequence. 1+2=3, 1+3=4. Here, the next interesting number occurs with one place shift: “12,345”. In the former, the number pattern increase is summing two adjacent numbers to produce the next in sequence. 1+2=3, 2+3=5. Here, the next number in the progression would be “12,358” (still with only one place increase). | |
Of course, “12,321” is the next palindrome, which is also interesting. | |
But, why “just” interesting and not fascinating? Well, I started playing with the numbers and what I found “fascinating” was that at a certain point it is the “visible” number which is easier to find interesting. For example: “12”, “123”, “1221”, “1234” are all visually appealing (to me). But, and I’m not sure why, “1,221” and “1,234” are less so. I’m leaning to the lack of symmetry caused by the “comma” between the “1” and the “2”. In which case, “123,321” becomes the next “true” visual palindrome. I’m not sure if the difference is “unique”, but it is unexpected (to me) and therefore, (to me) fascinating. Why? Because looking back at the original post, after passing the milestone, I realized I used the number “1221” in the title and not the comma delimited “1,221”. Somehow, I was unconsciously preferring the use (in the title) of the visual palindrome over the normal numeric representation even though logically they are equivalent. So, while the numbers are interesting, it was my recognition of use which (to me) is fascinating. | |
But, like I said, this is just me being me. | |
(PS: “LLAP” = “Live Long and Prosper“) | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | By Any Other Name (Or Description) |
2021 | Democracy, Pandemic, Economy And Climate Change |
Heaven Is… | |
2020 | Hoping For #46 In January 2021 |
2019 | Interesting, But Not Fascinating |
But Try To Eat The Low-Hanging First | |
2018 | Me, Too |
2017 | Apt Enough? |
2016 | Now Or Ever |
21, Pause, Restart | |
2015 | I Am Shocked, Sir, Shocked… |
Lucy & FSND-2 | |
2014 | Less Difficult |
2013 | The Spirit Of Liberty |
2012 | The Essential Freedom Of Aloneness |
2011 | A Problem Of Scale |
Fred Doesn’t Live Here Anymore | |
2010 | Another Book, Another Jog… |
But Try To Eat The Low-Hanging First
Posted in Philosophy, Quotes, tagged Fear, Fruit, H. Jackson Brown Jr., Limbs, Philosophy, Quotes on January 24, 2019| 4 Comments »
Don’t be afraid to go out on a limb. That’s where the fruit is. | |
— H. Jackson Brown, Jr. | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | By Any Other Name (Or Description) |
2021 | Democracy, Pandemic, Economy And Climate Change |
Heaven Is… | |
2020 | Hoping For #46 In January 2021 |
2019 | Interesting, But Not Fascinating |
But Try To Eat The Low-Hanging First | |
2018 | Me, Too |
2017 | Apt Enough? |
2016 | Now Or Ever |
21, Pause, Restart | |
2015 | I Am Shocked, Sir, Shocked… |
Lucy & FSND-2 | |
2014 | Less Difficult |
2013 | The Spirit Of Liberty |
2012 | The Essential Freedom Of Aloneness |
2011 | A Problem Of Scale |
Fred Doesn’t Live Here Anymore | |
2010 | Another Book, Another Jog… |
Your Only Choice
Posted in Philosophy, Quotes, tagged Bob Marley, Choices, Philosophy, Quotes, Strength on January 23, 2019| Leave a Comment »
You’ll never know how strong you are — until being strong is the ONLY choice you have! | |
— Bob Marley | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | And Even Fewer Regrets |
2021 | Today Counts |
I Hope You’ll Understand | |
2020 | Maybe #IncompetentDonald Really Is A Great Manager |
2019 | Your Only Choice |
2018 | A Good Definition |
2017 | Getting It Done |
2016 | Getting To Know Me |
2015 | Why I Pay Taxes |
2014 | Inequality Of Sacrifice |
2013 | I Never Saw A Moor |
2012 | Fill In The Blank |
Not For Naught | |
Cliff Notes To Life? | |
2011 | Conference Games Sunday |
Are You Done Watching?
Posted in Philosophy, Quotes, tagged Envy, Jim Rohn, Philosophy, Quotes on January 22, 2019| 3 Comments »
The few who do are the envy of the many who only watch. | |
— Jim Rohn | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | Enduring Success |
2021 | Dealing With Trumpism, Racism and Fascism In America |
Just Wondering | |
2020 | And So Must Good Government |
2019 | Are You Done Watching? |
2018 | Spineless Capitulation By The Democrats |
Woe Is Me… | |
2017 | Sincerely Yours |
2016 | Only Good To Say |
2015 | A Series Of Temporary Conditions |
2014 | Gaps |
2013 | Duty |
2012 | Cost Not Price |
Superheroes | |
2011 | The Simple Normalcy Of Everyday Life – “Squirrel!” |
#ContinueToResist
Posted in History, Politics, Quotes, tagged #ContinueToResist, #Resist, 2020 Census, Anyone But Trump, Citizens United, Cowards, Dark Money, Electoral College, History, Paul Ryan, Politics, President Abraham Lincoln, Protest, Reapportionment, Republicans, Rust Belt, Silence, Sin, South Carolina, Speaker of the House on January 21, 2019| Leave a Comment »
To sin by silence when they should protest, makes cowards of human beings. | |
— Abraham Lincoln | |
[It is vitally important to continue resisting the programs of President Trump and the Republican Senate. It is equally important to support the Democratic control of the House of Representatives. Remember, if there is no clear election in the Electoral College in 2020, the decision of who will be the next President will fall to the House of Representatives. I believe this is what the Republicans were actually hoping for when the “Anyone but Trump” Republican movement went silent. They didn’t have to get Trump elected President in the popular vote. The Republicans only had to tie up the Electoral College. In which case, Paul Ryan most probably would have been “elected” President. One: he was the Republican VP nominee in the prior election (2012). Normally, when the ticket fails, the VP choice is the next one in line to be put forward. And, two: Ryan was the Speaker of the House, which means he was already the “prime” person to be elevated from the House to the Oval Office. When (in 2016) Florida went to the Republicans and the House was retained by the Republicans, they only needed one of the Rust Belt states and South Carolina to stop Clinton, irrespective of her national popular vote count. The same conditions will be true in 2020, if the Republicans can somehow flip the House back to their control. | |
Added to that (final control of the Presidential election), the House also has primary responsibility for seat reapportionment after the 2020 census. If Republicans flip control back (to themselves) they will use even more gerrymandering to reduce the value of the popular vote. (Of course, this presumes the Republicans retain control of the majority of the State Houses, too. Since they control 32 States to the Dems 14, it seems likely they will.) Don’t misinterpret me. The Democratic Party will also gerrymander, but they “generally” do so to increase the value of the popular vote. They (the Democrats) “only” do this because the demographics of the future favor the the Democratic Party. Basically, older (mostly white male) voters are dying and the younger voters (across all genders, ethnic breakdown, income and education levels) replacing them on the voting roles are trending to the Democratic Party. And without newer ideas, the Conservative / Republican Party will continue to wither away. IMHO: It is only “Dark Money” and the Citizens United decision which have propped the Republican Party up this far. | |
A word to the wise should suffice… Stay engaged locally. #Resist — kmab] | |
. | |
On This Day In: | |
2022 | End The Filibuster |
2021 | Be Creative, Question Assumptions |
By No Means | |
2020 | I’ll Eat To That (Gemütlichkeit) |
To The Front | |
2019 | #ContinueToResist |
Except Willful Ignorance And Prideful Stupidity | |
2018 | More Executive Time For #DumbDonald |
2017 | Watched The Inauguration |
Two Geniuses | |
2016 | Come Dance And Laugh With Me |
2015 | Looks Good To Me |
2014 | Desire For The Sea |
2013 | The Fierce Urgency Of NOW |
Happy Inauguration Day! | |
2012 | One Path |
Sorrow And Joy | |
The Seven Year View | |
2011 | Emergent Practicality |